The focus of this lesson is comparing and contrasting proportional and non-proportional relationships. You may recall that in proportional relationships, the variables in the problem are related by a constant factor or ration.

Read the following situation and answer the questions below.

Jenny is comparing two online music download services. Company A offers music downloads for $0.99 per song. Company B offers music downloads for $0.49 per song after a $20.00 membership fee. To help her determine the better deal, Jenny creates a table for each company to compare costs.

Copy the tables below into your notes, and fill in the missing information based on the information given in the problem.

Company A

Number of Songs Process Cost to Download Cost per Song
5 5(.99) $4.95 $0.99
10   $9.90 $0.99
15      
20      
25      
30      
35      
40      
45      
50      

Company B

Number of Songs Process Cost to Download Cost per Song
5 20 + 5(.49) $22.45 $4.49
10   $24.90 $2.49
15      
20      
25      
30      
35      
40      
45      
50      

Interactive popup. Assistance may be required.

Click here if you need help completing your tables.

Hint:

To fill in the “Cost to Download” column for company A, multiply the number of songs by 0.99. 

To fill in the “Cost to Download” column for company B, multiply the number of songs by 0.49 and then add the product to 20.

To fill in the “Cost per Song” column, divide the cost to download by the number of songs.  (You may need to round to the nearest penny.) Close Pop Up

 

Click here to see the completed tables.

Company A

Number of Songs
Process Cost to Download Cost per Song
5

5(.99) $4.95 $0.99
10 10(.99) $9.90 $0.99
15 15(.99) $14.85 $0.99
20 20(.99) $19.80 $0.99
25 25(.99) $24.75 $0.99
30 30(.99) $29.70 $0.99
35 35(.99) $34.65 $0.99
40 40(.99) $39.60 $0.99
45 45(.99) $44.55 $0.99
50 50(.99) $49.50 $0.99


Company B

Number of Songs
Process Cost to Download Cost per Song
5 20 + 5(.49) $22.45 $4.49
10 20 + 10(.49) $24.90 $2.49
15 20 + 15(.49) $27.35 $1.82
20 20 + 20(.49) $29.80 $1.49
25 20 + 25(.49) $32.25 $1.29
30 20 + 30(.49) $34.70 $1.16
35 20 + 35(.49) $37.15 $1.06
40 20 + 40(.49) $39.60 $0.99
45 20 + 45(.49) $42.05 $0.94
50 20 + 50(.49) $44.50 $0.89
Close Pop Up

What do you notice about the cost per song for company A?
Interactive popup. Assistance may be required. Check Your Answer The cost per song remains constant.Close Pop Up

For company A, how can you find the cost of downloading any number of songs?
Interactive popup. Assistance may be required. Check Your Answer Multiply the number of songs by 0.99. Close Pop Up

What is the equation that relates y, the cost to download, to x, the number of songs, for company A?
Interactive popup. Assistance may be required. Check Your Answer y = 0.99xClose Pop Up

Keeping in mind that proportional relationships are in the form y = kx, is this a proportional relationship or a non-proportional relationship?
Interactive popup. Assistance may be required. Check Your Answer This is a proportional relationship.Close Pop Up

What do you notice about the cost per song for company B?
Interactive popup. Assistance may be required. Check Your Answer The cost per song decreases as you download more songs. Close Pop Up

What is the equation that relates to y, the cost to download, to x, the number of songs, for company B?
Interactive popup. Assistance may be required. Check Your Answer y = 20 + 0.49x Close Pop Up

Keeping in mind that proportional relationships are in the form y = kx, is this a proportional relationship or a non-proportional relationship?
Interactive popup. Assistance may be required. Check Your Answer This is a non-proportional relationship. Close Pop Up

Read the following problem, and fill in the missing values in the table.

Your parents are trying to get your little sister to help with the yard work.  They offer her a quarter for every 10 weeds she pulls and puts in a bucket. 
  


Weeds
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Pay                

Click here to see the completed table.

Company A

Weeds
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Pay $0.25 $0.50 $0.75 $1.00 $1.25 $1.50 $1.75 $2.00
Close Pop Up

What is the rate of pay?
Interactive popup. Assistance may be required. Check Your Answer The rate of pay is $0.25 for every 10 weeds. Close Pop Up

What is the unit rate for the following equation?
0.25 ÷ 10 = 0.025
Interactive popup. Assistance may be required. Check Your Answer The unit rate is 2.5 cents per weed. Close Pop Up

Does the ratio of pay number of weeds  change or stay the same in the problem?
Interactive popup. Assistance may be required. Check Your Answer The ratio stays the same. Close Pop Up

What equation could you write to calculate your little sister’s pay?
Interactive popup. Assistance may be required. Check Your Answer y = 0.025x Close Pop Up

Keeping in mind that proportional relationships are in the form y = kx, is this a proportional relationship or a non-proportional relationship?
Interactive popup. Assistance may be required. Check Your Answer This is a proportional relationship. Close Pop Up

How do you know?
Interactive popup. Assistance may be required. Check Your Answer The equation is y = kx. 
The rate of pay stays constant. Close Pop Up

What difference do you notice between the equations that represent proportional relationships and the equations that represent non-proportional relationships?
Interactive popup. Assistance may be required. Check Your Answer The equations for proportional relationships had multiplication only; the equation for the non-proportional relationship that we saw had both multiplication and addition. Close Pop Up